← All Authorities
Hong Kong

Paul Y Management Ltd v Eternal Unity Development Ltd (Cheung JA)

(CACV 16/2008) [2008] HKEC 1359
JurisdictionHong Kong
Year2008
Statusunclear

Key Principle

Court tests defence against contemporaneous documents, prior inconsistency, late raising, inherent probability — but no mini-trial

Area of Law

Civil Procedure — O.14 and O.14A summary judgment and point of law

Related Cases

Re Estate of Cha Mou Sing Payson (Deceased) (CA) [2024] 2 HKLRD 1411
Re Estate of Chan Fook Lai (Deceased) (CA) [2024] 1 HKLRD 29
Hui Tung v World Win Consultants Ltd (CA) [2023] HKCA 442

Ask CommonBench about this case

Get a detailed analysis of Paul Y Management Ltd v Eternal Unity Development Ltd (Cheung JA) and how it applies to your situation.

Explain Paul Y Management Ltd v Eterna...